Keeping Source Formatting with Layers!?

Hi!

Please someone tell me if there is a way to keep the source formatting when copying a layer from one slide and pasting it into another. I have the theme colors set as the same for all slides, but when I copy one layer from one slide to another slide (no paste special option appears), it automatically changes the colors of the layer and buttons which is a pain in the butt to have to change all the time.

I am crossing my fingers and toes that there is some workaround for this, but I have tried looking on here, Youtube, and Google to see and haven't found any solution. See pictures for an example of how it pastes.

Thank you!