Hello Darri! Thanks for reaching out.
I tried creating a sample screen recording (Try Mode) and left the slide properties to the default setting.
I also changed the Player resume setting to "Never resume." After that, I published it to Review and embedded it into my Rise course. I tried just sharing the course as well as uploading it to SCORM Cloud for testing (LMS) and in both instances, I was able to redo the entire activity every time I went back to that lesson. Here's a quick Peek recording (no audio) of what my test looked like.
Where was your course hosted? Have you tried publishing the Rise course to Review 360 or testing your course in SCORM Cloud to see if you'll be able to duplicate the behavior?
If you continue encountering the same behavior, you can upload your Storyline file or share your Rise course with us by opening a support case here. Our engineers will be more than happy to take a closer look at your concern.
